What simulation tools to use for SHIP?
 What simulation tools to use for SHIP?

What simulation tools to use for SHIP?

As use of solar heat in manufacturing is still at an early stage, planners and engineers require tools to model and compare differently sized systems and ideas for process integration. In August 2015, researchers working on SHC Task 49, Solar Heat Integration in Industrial Processes, published a list of suitable simulation software (see the attached report). Since then, the developers of these programs have added new features to facilitate the modelling of systems which provide solar heat for industrial processes (SHIP). 
Chart: T*SOL
The Task 49 researchers evaluated four commercially available tools – TRNSYS, T*SOL, POLYSUN and SOLTERM (see the table below) – as part of a project supported by the IEA Solar Heating and Cooling Programme.
NameType of softwareDeveloperType of collectorType of simulation (time increment)SHIP integration
TRNSYSResearchUniversity of Wisconsin-Madison, USAStationary and trackingQuasi-dynamic
(1 hour)
Preset load profiles
T*SOLSimplified designValentin Software, GermanyStationaryQuasi-dynamic
(6 minutes monthly; 1 hour for a year)
Preset load profiles
POLYSUNProfessional designVela Solaris, SwitzerlandStationary and trackingAutomated
(1 second to 12 minutes); cannot be changed
Preset and adjustable load profiles
SOLTERMSimplified designLNEG, PortugalStationary and tracking500 secondsPreset load profiles / hourly profiles / weekdays and weekends
Some of the features incorporated into four commercially available simulation tools, as listed in the Task 49 report. The document does not contain a detailed description of Solterm, because it was not used by the researchers.
Source: Task 49
Several tools were used in Task 49 (February 2012 to December 2015) to perform calculations based on case studies. Feedback was summarised as follows:
TRNSYS is flexible as it allows users to choose from a variety of models for collectors, storage tanks, controllers etc. Therefore, selecting another model for the same case study might lead to different results, so that TRNSYS is less practical for rather general studies. The program should be chosen whenever the description of the system is very detailed and components seem well-specified.
T*SOL is highly intuitive and takes little time to use. To model systems supplying industrial solar heat, it provides a number of standard configurations to allow for a quick start to calculating energy yields and system economics for a wide variety of industrial applications, such as preheating make-up water and heating closed process loops. Due to the preconfigured systems the modelling of complex hydraulic set-ups and corresponding control strategies (especially on the process side) is limited.
Polysun is, because of its graphical interface and component-based structure, intuitive and fast. The program offers some preconfigured models suited for basic solar process heat applications, such as preheating make-up water, heating closed process loops and integrating solar thermal devices into a system of steam pipelines. The process side includes a simplified heat sink design and may be extended and more detailed specified by the user. Additionally, the temperature of the process cannot exceed 250 °C.
The researchers found several limitations across the different tools:
  • Time increments are too large for rapid changes (e.g. in operation).
  • Limited number of hydraulic schemes for SHIP applications.
  • Limited options to model process heat applications (preset load profiles and low number of heat sinks).
The program developers have released updates to remove relevant limitations and expand the scope of SHIP plant models. “T*SOL 2018 now has two more hydraulic SHIP models with up to six solar circuits and up to six heat sinks, including one for process heat,” said Denise Dawes, International Marketing Manager at Valentin. Polysun programme administrator Andreas Wolf said a recent update of Polysun added a function to specify inlet and return temperatures for process heat applications via CSV files.
Software tools and organisations mentioned in this article:
IEA SHC Task 49: http://task49.iea-shc.org


Baerbel Epp

Bärbel Epp is Founder and Director of the German communication and market research agency solrico and editor-in-chief of solarthermalworld.org